Friday, Nov 20, 2026
|
Advertisement

Should Siraj Have Played? Fans Question India's Selection After NZ Fight Back

India’s decision to leave Mohammed Siraj out of the playing XI for first Test against New Zealand has set off a major debate among cricket fans and former players. The discussion started today after captain Shubman Gill announced India’s team for opening Test at Basin Reserve in Wellington.

Should Siraj Have Played? Fans Question India's Selection After NZ Fight Back
Should Siraj Have Played? Fans Question India's Selection After NZ Fight Back | Photo Credit: https://x.com/CricCrazyJohns/

India went with four men pace but left out the experienced Siraj. The selection was criticised after New Zealand came back from an early batting collapse to finish Day 1 on 243/5.

Advertisement

Why Was Mohammed Siraj Dropped?

India went into the Wellington Test with Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Prasidh Krishna and Anshul Kamboj as their four specialist fast bowlers.

Washington Sundar was picked as spin-bowling all-rounder and Ravindra Jadeja too was left out.

After winning the toss Gill said it was a tough decision to leave out Siraj and Gurnoor Brar because all the fast bowlers available had done well.

The Indian captain said the team management had spent a lot of time discussing what combination would work best for conditions.

Advertisement

However, the exclusion of Siraj surprised supporters too he had played overseas Test cricket.

Sunil Gavaskar Questions India's Selection

Former India captain Sunil Gavaskar was surprised by Siraj’s omission.

Speaking on Sony Sports Network Gavaskar said Siraj had never let India down and asked whether there was any reason to leave him out.

He also referred to the fast bowler’s recent rhythm and performances and said that selection was unexpected.

Former New Zealand all-rounder Scott Styris had a different view though. He backed Anshul Kamboj’s inclusion saying the young pacer can generate seam movement and trouble batters with accuracy.

That started an interesting debate about whether India should have gone for Siraj’s experience or the younger bowling combination.

Wasim Jaffer Also Criticises Siraj's Omission

Former India batter Wasim Jaffer also spoke up and said Siraj’s exclusion was shocking.

Jaffer praised Siraj for helping India perform better in Tests and how he builds pressure with consistent bowling.

He said the conditions in Wellington offered Siraj an opportunity to make an impact.

The criticism got louder still as New Zealand went from 70/5 at stumps to 243/5.

Did India's Decision Affect the Match?

India had initially seemed to have made the right call when Bumrah and the other fast bowlers had reduced New Zealand to 70/5.

Bumrah finished with three wickets while Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj picked up one wicket each.

However Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips changed the momentum with an unbeaten 173-run partnership.

Nicholls remained unbeaten on 113 while Phillips finished not out on 94.

The inability to break their partnership raised questions about whether Siraj’s experience and relentless bowling could have helped India keep the pressure on.

Should Siraj Have Been in India's Playing XI?

There are arguments on both sides. Siraj’s overseas experience, ability to bowl long spells and record in tough conditions made him a good candidate.

At the same time, the management wanted to reward other fast bowlers for recent form and felt that the combination selected would exploit Wellington’s conditions.

Ultimately it will all be about debate on Day 2 as India try to recover. Siraj’s absence has been one of the biggest talking points of the opening Test and fans are waiting to see if the bowling attack picked can justify management’s decision.

Comments