Friday, Nov 20, 2026
|
Advertisement

Apple Hits Back at Epic Games Over 122,000 Documents, Claims Search Exposed Sensitive Files

Apple has countered Epic Games’ claims that it improperly withheld more than 122,000 documents in their ongoing legal battle over App Store commissions.

Apple and Epic Games legal battle over App Store documents
Apple and Epic Games legal battle over App Store documents | Photo Credit: https://x.com/bradknowles

The iPhone maker says the search terms Epic proposed were too broad  they caught thousands of unrelated files and sensitive employee info as well.

Advertisement

The latest dispute is part of the companies’ long-running legal battle over Apple’s App Store policies and commissions it charges developers for purchases outside of the platform.

Epic Games recently accused Apple of not producing a large number of documents showing how it calculated its proposed commissions for purchases made through external payment links. Epic said Apple had withheld more than 122,000 documents found using search terms agreed to by both sides.

The gaming company said those records could contain information about Apple’s financial calculations, internal discussions and business decisions behind its proposed commission rates. Epic also asked the court to order Apple to turn over the documents and impose daily financial penalties if it didn’t meet the deadline.

However, Apple has denied Epic’s allegations that the search terms were not specific enough and produced too many irrelevant results.

Advertisement

Search terms like “commission” and “fee” captured documents that had little or nothing to do with the App Store dispute, Apple said in its latest court filing. The wildcard search for “commission" also returned references to government commissions and even documents mentioning sports commissioners.

Similarly, the search term “fee” was reported to bring up unrelated words (“feel”, “feed”, “feet” and “feedback”). Apple said these results show how “broadly designed search terms can produce misleading document counts.”

Apple went on to say that at least 95% of the initial group of documents found through the searches did not contain references to external payment links or related terminology. It also raised concerns about some of the sensitive material in there.

The company said the documents included personal tax and financial records of employees; medical information; details about unreleased products; passwords; investor relations materials and confidential legal communications.

Apple argued that handing them over without examination could reveal private information and legally protected material. Companies in litigation have to produce relevant documents, not every file that happens to match a search term.

The technology company also said that reviewing the entire collection would take “considerable additional time and resources” so Epic’s December 2 deadline was difficult to meet.

In addition Apple has proposed that if the court feels further examination is necessary a randomly selected statistically significant sample of disputed documents could be reviewed by an independent Special Master.

The dispute comes as the companies continue to fight over rules for external payment options in Apple’s App Store how Apple charges developers if they buy outside of its ecosystem could be one of the results.

For now both companies are sticking to their guns and it is up to the court how to handle those documents. The latest dispute brings another chapter to one of technology’s most closely watched legal battles.

Comments