Karnataka Home Minister Priyank Kharge has levelled serious allegations of phone tapping across the country that mobile phones of political leaders (Chief Minister and even Home Minister) are being tapped. His comments came in the wake of Congress leader and Lok Sabha Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi alleging that Prime Minister Narendra Modi was monitoring his phone calls.
Kharge asked what kind of surveillance is happening at the Centre level and whether Pegasus spyware was bought and used by Centre illegally. Political debate on privacy, government surveillance and misuse of investigative technologies resumed once again.
Responding to Rahul Gandhi’s allegations, Priyank Kharge said phone tapping was not just with opposition leaders but with many others holding constitutional and administrative positions. Even the Chief Minister’s phone could be tapped, says Karnataka Home Minister; his own phone is being tapped despite having the Home portfolio, he also alleged. This has given a new dimension to political controversy over electronic surveillance: whether it is happening to everyone or only some elected representatives?
Kharge also asked the Centre whether the spyware (a sophisticated surveillance software developed by Israel-based NSO Group) had been purchased by India and if so, how and against whom it is being used.
Pegasus has been at the centre of political and legal controversies in India ever since allegations were made that it was used to target journalists, politicians, activists and others. Karnataka minister said the alleged surveillance practices are part of a larger strategy to put opposition leaders under pressure and restrict their ability to question the government.
Calling it the “Gujarat model”, Kharge said the BJP-led Central Government was intimidating and surveilling political opponents to silence them. Opposition leaders who ask questions on governance and national issues are being pressured instead of getting answers from those in power, he said, adding that the government should be held accountable for what it does, especially when concerns relate to citizens’ fundamental rights, individual privacy and democratic freedoms. He also asked whether surveillance mechanisms were used for national security or political interests.
Karnataka Home Minister also attacked the Centre for its performance in the past decade and said it had not achieved much on several important fronts.
Unemployment, India’s relationship with China and Pakistan and other national issues need to be discussed and held accountable, Kharge alleged and added that when opposition parties ask questions on these issues from the government, they are intimidated or controlled rather than asked questions. A healthy democracy says the government must respond to criticism and opposition parties should be allowed to perform their constitutional duties without fear, he asserted.
The allegations have once again put digital surveillance and political accountability back on the national agenda. Phone tapping and alleged spyware are two sensitive subjects in Indian politics, especially with personal communications and the privacy of public figures being at stake.
Surveillance for legitimate security purposes is legal, but allegations of unauthorised monitoring can lead to serious questions about accountability and protection of civil liberties. Kharge’s latest remarks will only ramp up the political confrontation between Congress and BJP as the opposition wants more transparency from the Centre over Pegasus and surveillance issues.
But specific allegations of phone tapping made by the Karnataka Home Minister have not been independently established yet; further evidence or an official response from the concerned authorities would be needed to establish them.
Comments