An Italian politician has sparked an international political row after he criticised India’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) at Bharat Summit 2026 in Hyderabad.
Deborah Bergamini, a senior leader of Italy’s Forza Italia party and ally of Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, gave a strong reaction to the remarks.
Bergamini criticised Giacomo Filibeck, Secretary-General of the Party of European Socialists (PES) for commenting on India’s domestic political issues: “It is not appropriate for representatives of Europe to lecture India on democracy when it has its own democratic institutions and judicial system.”
The row began when Filibeck attended Bharat Summit organised by Indian National Congress in Hyderabad on 13 and 14 November. He addressed the gathering there and backed Congress leader Rahul Gandhi’s campaign against alleged irregularities in electoral rolls.
Filibeck also repeated the Congress slogan Vote Chor Gaddi Chhod (Vote thieves, leave your seats). He criticised Narendra Modi led government and said democracy in India was under threat.
Filibeck praised Rahul Gandhi for defending “one person, one vote”. He also mentioned the Congress campaign for clean and transparent voter lists and support for efforts to protect democratic rights.
His remarks were immediately political because they came from a foreign political representative speaking at an event put on by an Indian opposition party.
Responding to the controversy, Bergamini said democratic societies allow people and political parties to express their opinions and make allegations so long as they can back them up. But she questioned why a foreign representative should come in to India’s internal political discussions.
She also noted India’s large electorate 970 million eligible voters. Bergamini said that “India has political institutions and a judiciary which can deal with disputes and grievances through democratic procedures”.
Bergamini also referred to the special strategic partnership between India and Italy, saying relations between friendly countries should be based on mutual respect and cooperation.
The controversy has also led to reactions from Indian political leaders. Union Home Minister Amit Shah hit out at Rahul Gandhi over his international summit remarks, saying the Congress leader was using foreign platforms to tarnish India’s image.
Union Minister Kiren Rijiju also questioned the Congress leadership’s response to Filibeck’s comments. BJP spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari said separately that opposition was seeking foreign support in domestic politics.
Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Sanjay Raut also defended Filibeck’s right to express his views while the political debate took another turn . The incident has renewed debate on electoral transparency, foreign political commentary and India’s democratic institutions.
An Italian leader of Meloni’s political alliance has publicly defended India’s democratic framework and the controversy has also shown how important diplomatic ties between New Delhi and Rome are. The exchange is still political fodder in India and abroad.
Comments