A political controversy has erupted in Mumbai over Sonia Gandhi’s memoir Belonging: A Journey of Love. Shiv Sena leaders Shaina NC, Sanjay Nirupam and Anand Dubey protested against the book, saying that it gives a distorted account of history and disrespects freedom fighter Veer Savarkar.
On November 18, the protesters tore pages from copies of the book and demanded HarperCollins India remove passages they objected to. The protest has added another chapter to the political debate over Sonia Gandhi’s memoir released recently.
Shiv Sena Leaders Protest Against Sonia Gandhi's Book
The demonstration was led by Shiv Sena leaders who objected to references to Veer Savarkar and other historical matters in the book.
Shaina NC, Sanjay Nirupam and Anand Dubey were among those who took part in the protest. They accused the author of whitewashing history and making statements that they said were disrespectful to Savarkar.
The protesters tore pages from the book publicly to show their opposition and also asked HarperCollins India to review the disputed content and remove passages they found objectionable.
The protesters “specifically pointed out” (reports of the demonstration said) pages 201 and 443 as having passages they wanted removed. Some reports have given different page numbers, so check against the edition of the book.
Why Is Sonia Gandhi's Memoir Facing Criticism?
Belonging: A Journey of Love is Sonia Gandhi’s memoir in which she talks about her personal journey, family, politics and association with India’s public life.
Since its release, the book has been widely discussed, and several political leaders have commented on it (descriptions of historical events and political personalities).
The Shiv Sena protest isn’t the only controversy over the memoir. BJP leaders have also lashed out at it, saying Sonia Gandhi has presented certain episodes of India’s political history in a way that protects the Congress party legacy.
But Congress leaders and supporters have defended the memoir as a personal account of Sonia Gandhi’s life and point of view.
#WATCH | Mumbai: Shiv Sena leaders Shaina NC, Sanjay Nirupam, Anand Dubey and others protested against Sonia Gandhi's book Belonging, accusing it of whitewashing history and denigrating Veer Savarkar. During the demonstration, they tore pages from the book and demanded that publisher HarperCollins remove passages on pages 201 and 443
— ANI (@ANI) November 18, 2026
HarperCollins Asked to Remove Disputed Passages
At the Mumbai protest Shiv Sena leaders demanded HarperCollins India take action on the disputed sections and said references to Veer Savarkar should be examined carefully.
The protesters also wanted the passages they considered objectionable excised. This puts the publisher at the centre of the latest controversy surrounding the memoir.
As of November 18 no official response from HarperCollins India had been received on this specific removal demand.
Political Debate Around 'Belonging' Continues
The Mumbai demonstration shows how political reactions to Sonia Gandhi’s memoir are increasing — criticism as well as support.
Shiv Sena leaders have demanded changes to the book, but the controversy has also reignited debate about how political memoirs depict history and influential people.
For now, the demand to remove the disputed passages is what protesters are pushing as the central issue. Whether HarperCollins India will respond to that demand remains to be seen.
Comments